1. Memori
  2. ›
  3. Articles

The "Why" Phase: When Not Answering Is the Right Move

By Leon MoriguchiPublished May 13, 2026Updated May 18, 20266 min read日本語版あり
Audience
Parents of children ages 2–5

TL;DR

  • ·Children produce 76–95 information-seeking questions per hour on average, and they actively evaluate whether a response qualifies as an explanation — pushing back or proposing their own if it doesn't
  • ·Saying "I don't know" or returning the question ("What do you think?") protects the child's inquiry better than a vague or invented answer, which can signal that the question isn't worth exploring
  • ·Children's intuitive theories (like the gravity bias) are the backdrop against which every answer lands; understanding that context makes the "why" phase considerably more interesting to live in

Contents

  1. Lead
  2. "Why" Questions Are a Primary Mode of Cognitive Search
  3. When Children Don't Get an Explanation, They Push Back
  4. "I Don't Know" Is Often the Correct Answer
  5. Practical Options When "Why?" Arrives
  6. Summary
  7. References

Lead

"Why does it rain?" "Why can't dogs talk?" "Why does Daddy have to go to work?" Why, why, why.

You try, once, to answer properly. You explain the water cycle. You touch on mammalian vocal anatomy. You begin edging toward household finances. By the third question you notice something: the child is not listening for the answer. Or rather, the answer is not what they came for.

The "why" phase is often treated as a test of parental knowledge and endurance. But the developmental research points in the opposite direction. Give a precise answer and the child's inquiry stops. What is being tested is not your knowledge — it may be your ability to not answer.

Partner Ultra / Ultra only

The rest of this article is for Partner Ultra / Ultra members

Anything affecting your child's health and safety is free. The more advanced reading is available to Memori members in the app.

Read the full article in the appSign in to keep reading →

Already a member? Sign in and the rest appears right here.

In the memori app

The memori app is built to follow your child against their own past, not against an average.

  • First roll, first word — milestones are kept with their dates.
  • Height, weight and head circumference are drawn over national reference curves.
  • You can find photos with a phrase like "at the beach last summer."
More about memori →
← PreviousBiting, Hitting, Kicking — The Developmental Trajectory of Physical AggressionNext →When to Step In — and When Not To — During Preschool Friendship Conflicts

Related

  • From Scribble to Figure: How Children's Drawing Actually Develops
  • Lying and Theory of Mind: Observe Before You Scold
  • Pretend Play and Theory of Mind: What the Research Actually Says